It’s not enough to break up Big Tech. We need to imagine a better alternative | Evgeny Morozov

Presenting tech companies as Americas greatest menace may appeal to voters, but it does little to chart an alternative future

As Facebook all but pleads guilty to a severe form of data addiction, confessing its digital sins and promising to reinvent itself as a privacy-worshiping denizen of the global village, the foundations of Big Techs cultural hegemony appear to be crumbling. Most surprisingly, its in the United States, Silicon Valleys home territory, where they seem to be the weakest.

  • A Bestselling Ebook Packed With Information About How To Buy Items For The Lowest Prices
  • Streams of Traffic To Your Websites and Sales Pages Using Simple Methods
  • Discover The Fat Loss Accelerators Workout Plans To Get Rid Of Your Ugly Belly Fat
  • Discover A Habit Busting Program Gives You The Ability You Have Always Wanted.
  • Are you frustrated that your expensive karoke player does not let you play.
  • Brainwave entrainment to listerally transform your life which can you get more inspiration.
  • Learn how you can easily create mobile apps to generate passive income.
  • Know The 3 Essential Steps To Instantly Fire Up Your Testicles And Testosterone
  • Learn How To Seduce Any Women By Unlock The Window Into Her Mind, Her Body And Her Emotions
  • Ultimate collections of 50 marketing graphics for one crazy low prize.
  • Know The Delicious Easy-To-Make Smoothies For Weight Loss And Incredible Health
  • The 100 Day Marathon Plan. Helps All-level-runners Achieve Their Marathon Goals.
  • So the strategy SteadyWinner using can be called, in academic terms, a trend-following mean-re
  • The big book of home remedies-ebook a complete a-z guide with nearly 2000 homemade remedies.
  • How to overcome all types of fertility and fall pregnant even if you are over 40
  • Know the 6 sensible strategies that will help to transform your body.
  • Discover The Secret That Gives You His Password To Unlock His Heart and Make Him Love You.
  •  

    Even in these times of extreme polarization, Trump, who has habitual outbursts against censorship by social media platforms, eagerly joins left-wing politicians like Elizabeth Warren and Bernie Sanders in presenting Big Tech as Americas greatest menace The recent call by Chris Hughes, Facebooks co-founder, to break up the firm hints at things to come.

    Neither the Silicon Valley moguls nor financial markets seem to care though. The recent decision by Warren Buffet one of Americas most successful but also most conservative investors to finally invest in Amazon is probably a better indication of wait awaits the tech giants in the medium term: more lavish initial public offerings, more Saudi cash, more promises to apply artificial intelligence to resolve the problems caused by artificial intelligence.

    More than a year after the Cambridge Analytical scandal, the Big Tech debate is still mired in the same hackneyed categories of market efficiency, tax evasion, and odious business models that had launched it. If we are going to break up Facebook, shouldnt we at least break it up for reasons other than its effects on competition or consumer welfare?

    The two ideological camps, despite their presumed convergence on the Big Tech issue, are unlikely to use this debate to reinvent their own political projects. Those on the right who hope to score electoral points by bashing Big Tech are still mum on what their preferred alternative future looks like. Furthermore, in as much as these movements pine for the return of a conservative and corporativist society ruled by forces seated outside of elected institutions, Silicon Valley, with its extensive digital infrastructure for permanent soft governance, is their natural ally.

    Mark
    Mark Zuckerberg speaks during the F8 Facebook Developers conference in April. Photograph: Justin Sullivan/Getty Images

    In the international context, this insistence on salvation by Big Tech acquires an extra twist as theres so much more salvation and, also, national development to be meted out by those very technology giants. This prompts some populist leaders to fantasize about turning their entire countries into efficiently-run fiefdoms of some Big Tech overlord. Thus, the Bolsonaro government in Brazil has proudly announced that they dream of having Google or Amazon take over the national post office, soon to be privatized.

    Todays crisis-prone Brazil reveals yet another consequence of surrendering the space formerly occupied by politics to the savior-industrial complex of Big Tech. The long-term effect of their supposedly revolutionary activity is often to actually cement the status quo, even if they do it by means of extremely disruptive solutions.

    Nowhere is this more evident than in how digital technologies are being used to deal with the most burning of social problems. Thus, as crime rates have skyrocketed, Brazil has become a hotbed of innovation in what we might call Survival Tech, with a panoply of digital tools being used to check on the safety of particular streets and neighborhoods and coordinate joint community-level responses.

    Thus, Waze, a popular Alphabet-owned navigation app, already alerts users in large cities like So Paulo or Rio de Janeiro that they are about to enter a risky part of town (the provenance of the data that is feeding such recommendations has been quite murky). Likewise, residents concerned with crime rates in their own neighborhoods increasingly use tools like Whatsapp to share tips about any suspicious activities in the area.

    As things get worse and not just in Brazil such Survival Tech, allowing citizens to get by in the face of adversity without demanding any ambitious social transformation, stands to flourish. The last decade, with its celebration of austerity, has been good for business as well. In fact, the entire technology boom that followed the 2007-08 financial crisis can be effectively explained through this lens, with venture capitalists and, later, sovereign wealth funds, temporarily subsidizing the mass production of Survival Tech for the dispossessed and the disaffected.

    Survival Tech, however, is too lousy of a brand to merit its own conferences or laudatory manifestos. Instead, we prefer to celebrate the sharing economy (with startups helping the poor survive by accepting precarious jobs or renting out their possessions), the smart city (with cities surrendering their technological sovereignty in exchange for temporarily free services to the digital giants), the fin tech (with next-generation payday loans based on user data being marketed as a revolution in financial inclusion).

  • Learn how you can easily create mobile apps to generate passive income.
  • A Bestselling Ebook Packed With Information About How To Buy Items For The Lowest Prices
  • Discover The Fat Loss Accelerators Workout Plans To Get Rid Of Your Ugly Belly Fat
  • Discover A Habit Busting Program Gives You The Ability You Have Always Wanted.
  • Are you frustrated that your expensive karoke player does not let you play.
  • Brainwave entrainment to listerally transform your life which can you get more inspiration.
  • Know The 3 Essential Steps To Instantly Fire Up Your Testicles And Testosterone
  • Streams of Traffic To Your Websites and Sales Pages Using Simple Methods
  • Learn How To Seduce Any Women By Unlock The Window Into Her Mind, Her Body And Her Emotions
  • Protect Your Family with Parental Controls Download Internet Filter Now
  • Know the 6 sensible strategies that will help to transform your body.
  • Discover One Weird Trick That Forces Your Body To Eliminate Hemorrhoids In 48 Hours
  • The Latest Boat Design Software Start building your dream Boat In 5 Mins
  •  

    Unless the underlying economic conditions improve an unlikely proposition governments will continue their implicit alliance with the technology industry: this is the only way to guarantee that the masses, increasingly unhappy with the massive fiscal and behavioral sacrifices expected of them eg the prospect of higher environmental taxes already stokes riots in Europe get at least a modicum of security and prosperity, however short-term and illusory.

    Hence, we arrive at todays paradoxical outcome, whereby 99% of technological disruption is there to merely ensure that nothing of substance gets disrupted at all. Pathology persists we just adapt to it better, with sensors, maps, AI, and why not? quantum computing. The real gospel of todays Big Tech sanctioned and celebrated by governments is innovation for the sake of conservation.

    Such programs might be launched and celebrated under the banner of digital transformation but, in reality, they imply very little conscious and guided social transformation at all. Rather, what is sold under that label is the very opposite idea, ie the notion that individuals and institutions need to adapt to not to transform the technological world around them. As preached today, digital transformation is all about transforming institutions and individuals to match the seemingly unchangeable social conditions not the other way around.

    The favorite policies of todays progressives breaking up the Big Tech or even redistributing their data might resolve some real problems. But its hard to see how such measures would undermine the world of Survival Tech. After all, such virtual gear can be perfectly furnished by hundreds of start-ups the alternative world of Small and Humane Tech, so beloved by Silicon Valleys critics and not just by the likes of Microsoft or Amazon.

    In contrast, we can imagine an alternative future world of Rebel Tech, which does not perceive social conditions as set in stone, to be accepted and adjusted to, by means of latest technologies. Instead, it deploys bespoke technologies to alter, shape, and yes rebel against entrenched social conditions. The distinctions between Survival Tech and Rebel Tech are not philosophical or eternal; clever policy can get us more of the latter and less of the former.

    Breaking up the tech giants, having them pay a fair share of taxes, making better use of their data are all necessary but, alas, insufficient conditions for effective social not just individual or institutional transformation. Today, such nominally progressive slogans are often made from depressingly conservative vantage points. They imply that, as long as the tech industry accepts its responsibility as the anointed successor to the car industry becoming, in the best of cases, the ecologically-friendlier driver of economic growth we would eventually go back to the comfy and prosperous social-democratic world of the 1960s or 1970s.

    As appealing as this vision might seem, it merely camouflages the lack of any strategic thinking on behalf of the progressive or social democratic forces that are backing it. The rise of Big Tech is a consequence, not the cause, of our underlying political and economic crises; we will not resolve them merely by getting rid of the Big Tech or constraining their operations.

    Small and Humane Tech might be of some help. However, without an overarching vision and a concrete plan for ditching Survival Tech in favor of Rebel Tech, progressive forces would not have much to say about technology and, by extension, of contemporary politics as well. Small tech cannot afford to be so small-minded.

    • Evgeny Morozov is a Guardian US columnist

    Original Article : HERE ; The Ultimate Survival Food: The Lost Ways

     

  • Are you frustrated that your expensive karoke player does not let you play.
  • Discover A Habit Busting Program Gives You The Ability You Have Always Wanted.
  • Learn How To Seduce Any Women By Unlock The Window Into Her Mind, Her Body And Her Emotions
  • Learn how you can easily create mobile apps to generate passive income.
  • Know The 3 Essential Steps To Instantly Fire Up Your Testicles And Testosterone
  • Brainwave entrainment to listerally transform your life which can you get more inspiration.
  • Discover The Fat Loss Accelerators Workout Plans To Get Rid Of Your Ugly Belly Fat
  • A Bestselling Ebook Packed With Information About How To Buy Items For The Lowest Prices
  • Streams of Traffic To Your Websites and Sales Pages Using Simple Methods
  • Shows you how to really deal with a full post-disaster collapse using alternative medicine.
  • Nearly 100,000 copies soldUpdated and revised for 2017
  • Revolutionary M1/M5 Indicator. Big Results. Fast.
  • TRANSFORMING PHOTOS OF REAL PEOPLE INTO CARICATURES
  • The Latest Boat Design Software Start building your dream Boat In 5 Mins
  • Download Top-Rated Driver Update Tool and amp; Get Unlimited 64-Bit Drivers.
  • Use this secrets to hit longer, more accurate shots in only 15 minutes a day.
  • Protect Your Family with Parental Controls Download Internet Filter Now
  • The stunning secret of turning your wife on with the push of a button.
  • You can start to flip websites for profit right now, within the next hour.
  • The 100 Day Marathon Plan. Helps All-level-runners Achieve Their Marathon Goals.
  • A course of instructions and exercises in developing color consciousness.
  •